!! History Commons Alert, Exciting News

Context of 'November 23, 2010: Minnesota Lawmaker Detained for Approaching Women’s Clinic Carrying Pistol'

This is a scalable context timeline. It contains events related to the event November 23, 2010: Minnesota Lawmaker Detained for Approaching Women’s Clinic Carrying Pistol. You can narrow or broaden the context of this timeline by adjusting the zoom level. The lower the scale, the more relevant the items on average will be, while the higher the scale, the less relevant the items, on average, will be.

Mark Crutcher.Mark Crutcher. [Source: Life Dynamics]Members of the anti-abortion organization Life Dynamics call Planned Parenthood clinics in 49 states, pretending to be teenaged girls pregnant by older men, and use the clinics’ promises of confidentiality to accuse them of covering up sexual abuse. The group secretly records telephone conversations with some 800 receptionists and staff members, and then uses selectively edited snippets of the taped conversations in a national publicity campaign against Planned Parenthood. The intent of the organization is to discredit Planned Parenthood and other abortion providers, and to encourage lawsuits against them, according to information published on the organization’s Web site. Life Dynamics, based in Denton, Texas, claims that the tapes are “evidence” that Planned Parenthood and other women’s clinics are complicit in child sex abuse. The organization’s founder, Mark Crutcher, releases a report called “Child Predators,” which is picked up by, among other news outlets, Newsday and Fox News. The organization’s evidence fails to hold up under scrutiny by law enforcement officials and media outlets, and pro-choice attorneys and advocates raise questions about the legality of Life Dynamics’s tactics. The organization bills itself as a “political marketing agency” whose stated goal is to prevent women from obtaining abortions, even if they are legally entitled to them. Crutcher and the group have previously attempted to claim that abortions cause breast cancer, and that Planned Parenthood trafficked in human body parts; both claims have been solidly debunked. Roger Evans of Planned Parenthood notes: “No one has an obligation to report or to conduct an inquisition based on a phone call, because you have no idea who is on the other end and what the truth is. And in this case, [the] Life Dynamics hoax caller was scrupulously careful not to give a name.” He goes on to say that law enforcement officials who have investigated the Life Dynamics charges “have been satisfied that people are conscientiously complying with the law as it’s written, and that people are reporting when kids are in danger.” Life Dynamics denies that its covert recording of the conversations is a violation of any state or federal laws (though 13 states targeted by the organization have anti-wiretapping laws), and is working diligently to spread its story throughout the press, starting with right-wing advocacy groups. The magazine Citizen, published by James Dobson’s Christian group Focus on the Family, says in a cover story that the tapes will “bring down Planned Parenthood.” And Neal Horsley’s far-right Nuremberg Files Web site features a story by Massachusetts attorney Greg Hession that outlines a strategy for “pro-life attorneys” to pursue in filing criminal and civil charges against Planned Parenthood. [Womens ENEws, 11/10/2002] (Horsley is an acknowledged advocate for the murder of abortion providers—see January 1997.) [Feminist Women's Health Center News, 2010] Evans says that if Life Dynamics achieves its stated objective of forcing medical providers to report all instances of teenagers’ sexual activity, “The system would be deluged,” and, in the absence of confidentiality, he predicts “teenagers would stop coming in.” [Womens ENEws, 11/10/2002]

Entity Tags: Roger Evans, Greg Hession, Focus on the Family, Mark Crutcher, Life Dynamics, Planned Parenthood

Timeline Tags: US Health Care

State Representative Paul Hackbarth (R-MN) is filmed outside a women’s health clinic carrying a pistol.State Representative Paul Hackbarth (R-MN) is filmed outside a women’s health clinic carrying a pistol. [Source: WCCO-TV]Minnesota Republican State Representative Tom Hackbarth is handcuffed and detained by police after coming to a Planned Parenthood clinic in St. Paul with a revolver on his hip. Hackbarth is not arrested, but police temporarily confiscate his gun. Hackbarth is caught on video surveillance cameras parking his pickup truck in the clinic parking lot, exiting the vehicle with a loaded .38 Smith and Wesson in a holster, and walking down a dark alley behind the clinic. A clinic security guard spots Hackbarth “loitering” behind the clinic, and calls the police; they detain Hackbarth shortly after he drives away from the clinic. A search of the vehicle turns up a map of the area and a clip for another weapon, a .357 pistol. Hackbarth, the new chairman of the House Environment and Natural Resources Committee, is stripped of his leadership position after the incident. He says he had no intention of inciting any violence at the clinic, and denies even being aware that he had driven to a women’s health clinic. Instead, he says he was attempting to meet a woman whom he met via an online dating service, and admits that he and his wife are separated. “She gave me some line of baloney, and I thought, ‘well, she’s fibbing to me,’” Hackbarth explains. “You could tell, and I thought, ‘well, I’m going to check it out,’ and I went there to see if she was around and her vehicle was not there. And I was just checking on her.… Sure enough, she lied to me and I’m done with it.” The police report says Hackbarth may have been jealous over another man, an explanation he denies, though he tells police he is “jealous” about his “girlfriend.” The police report also says Hackbarth exhibited the behavior of a stalker: angry, looking for a woman, carrying a loaded weapon, and the police cite him for “stalking-like behavior” and borderline “harassment or terroristic threats.” Hackbarth says: “I have a permit to carry legally. I carry my gun all the time. I have never had an incident and everything is perfectly legal and above board.… What did I do that was so bad? According to me, all I did was go to an empty parking lot and parked my truck… walked around the block, and picked up the car and left.” He calls the police allegations “insane.” Neither the police nor the local press can confirm the identity of the woman Hackbarth says he went to meet; Hackbarth claims he has no contact information on her, cannot remember the Web site on which he says he met her, and only identifies her as “Linda.” He claims they have dated “one or two times.” Police state they consider the case closed. [WCCO-TV, 11/24/2010; Raw Story, 11/24/2010; St. Paul Pioneer-Press, 11/24/2010; KARE-11, 11/24/2010]

Entity Tags: Tom Hackbarth, Planned Parenthood

Timeline Tags: US Health Care

According to data reported by the Sunlight Foundation, Crossroads GPS, the organization raising and spending money on behalf of Republican candidates in the presidential election, reported spending $500,000 on ads attacking President Obama in Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, and Missouri. Those ads are somewhat countered by $36,000 of ads aired by Planned Parenthood Action Fund in Florida and Michigan. Under campaign finance law, groups such as these are not required to reveal their donors, though they are required to periodically reveal to the Federal Election Commission (FEC) that the ads have been bought, and how much was spent on them. One of Crossroads GPS’s ads accuses Obama of funneling government money to failed projects such as solar panel maker Solyndra, and ignoring those laid off by these companies. The Planned Parenthood ad lauds Obama for protecting access to affordable birth control. Crossroads GPS is a veteran in the post-Citizens United campaign finance world, having spent some $16 million in the 2010 elections, while the Planned Parenthood group is a relatively new player in the field, making its first expenditures on behalf of House candidate Kathy Hochul in 2011. [Sunlight Foundation, 2/7/2012]

Entity Tags: Planned Parenthood Action Fund, American Crossroads GPS, Barack Obama, Solyndra Corporation, Federal Election Commission, Sunlight Foundation, Kathleen Hochul

Timeline Tags: Civil Liberties, 2012 Elections

Ordering 

Time period


Email Updates

Receive weekly email updates summarizing what contributors have added to the History Commons database

 
Donate

Developing and maintaining this site is very labor intensive. If you find it useful, please give us a hand and donate what you can.
Donate Now

Volunteer

If you would like to help us with this effort, please contact us. We need help with programming (Java, JDO, mysql, and xml), design, networking, and publicity. If you want to contribute information to this site, click the register link at the top of the page, and start contributing.
Contact Us

Creative Commons License Except where otherwise noted, the textual content of each timeline is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike